Long Bow 1978
A |
This article originally appeared in Geo magazine. June 1980, and is reprinted by permission.
Thirty years ago, the sounds heard in the
Today, the dominant sound in Long Bow is no longer a country
sound but the shrill wail of steam locomotives in the railroad shops,
testing their eerie voices against a background roar of army tanks
racing across the proving grounds on the flanks of Great Ridge Hill.
There is an accompanying cacophany of truck, bus, and jeep horns on the
highway as frustrated drivers try to make their way through a stream of
handcarts, donkey carts, tractor-drawn wagons, bicycles, and
pedestrians.
Inside the village, a lesser background roar rolls from the big
grinder of the production brigade's cement plant, while from the long
shed that was once a meeting hall, the high whine of carborundum on
steel shreds the air. There, young women working in shifts around the
clock polish saw blades that will be exported to
The tower of the old church was torn down long ago. The brigade
leaders have installed a loudspeaker on the roof of their headquarters,
and their booming voices can be heard in the farthest fields. For many
years, they relied on loudspeaker "broadcasts" to regulate the
collective production that came into full flower in 1958. The
loudspeaker blasted forth before dawn to wake people up, at
In 1979, individual earnings were brought more closely in line
with individual effort, so that material reward became the primary
incentive to hard work. At the same time electronic exhortation,
discipline by loudspeaker, was abandoned. The air over the village was
turned back to the cocks that still crow before dawn and the peddlers
who still hawk their wares in the alleys. But they can never hope to
recapture the attention they once took for granted. There is too much
background noise from the many locomotives in the railroad yards.
As things used to be, one could look down from the summit of
Great Ridge Hill and see the whole of Long Bow stretched out on the
plain like a map. The polarization of village society was clearly
revealed by the contrast between the adobe huts of the poor peasants
and hired laborers, roofed with mud and straw, and the high brick
dwellings of the landlords and rich peasants, roofed with tile. Gentry
families occupied whole courtyards while poor peasants bedded down in
whatever ramshackle sections of walled enclosure they could find. That
was before the land reform giving land to individual peasants, which
took place in
Today, all that can be seen from the hill is a mass of greenery.
A special crew began to plant trees in Long Bow as soon as the
cooperative was created by the land-pooling movement in 1954. In the
intervening years, more than 250,000 trees have been planted, and they have
transformed the whole character of the settlement. The desolate,
sunbaked, semiruined earthworks of the past, open to all the violence
of heaven, have become a cool, shaded, gardenlike complex of
interlocking courtyards, streets, and alleys that offer protection
against the extremes of all seasons.
Beneath
the green of the newly planted trees, the predominant color of most
Chinese villages in the North is still the glowing tan of natural
adobe. Not so Long Bow. When the brigade leaders heard that foreign
guests were coming in 1971, they mobilized the whole community to
whitewash the walls on both sides of all the main streets, making the
predominant color a dazzling white. The ever present crimson slogans
stand out on this background as if molded in three dimensions.
Whitewashing apparently pleased the inhabitants, because they have kept
it up through all the years since.
In 1971, Long Bow undertook another civic improvement. All the
privies built along the streets, in anticipation of a contribution to
the family store of fertilizer from anyone passing by, were removed.
Now all privies are hidden away in courtyards, and ever since the
brigade built its own cement plant, the deep cisterns are covered with
concrete slabs that discourage flies, or at least the fly maggots down
below. The latter require more fresh air than can circulate under a
concrete cover, even one with a slot in it. This improvement has won
Long Bow a citation for excellence in public health. But while the
concrete slabs have certainly improved sanitation, they have not
entirely done away with the background odor of night soil that is
characteristic of the whole Chinese countryside -- and is in part
responsible for that welcome sense of déjà vu that overwhelms one on
returning.
Of the famous Dazhai Brigade, high on
High mountains, rock-strewn
slopes,
Step out the door, start
climbing up or down.
The popular rhyme about Long Bow stressed the opposite natural features:
Flat land, high watertable,
Step out the door, walk five
li without interruption.
Yet somehow, Dazhai peasants managed to harvest over 100 bushels
of grain per acre, while for many years, Long Bow peasants failed to
harvest even 30. Even though Mao said that "irrigation is the lifeblood
of agriculture," Long Bow peasants failed to make use of their ample
water supplies. Every winter the higher authorities mobilized Long Bow
for a big effort to prepare the land for more water, and every spring
it became clear that very little had been done. The authorities lost
patience with this sluggish community and labeled Long Bow an "old,
big, difficult place."
The real reason for this sluggishness was the character of Long
Bow soil. The more the peasants watered the land, the more intractable
it became. Water brought up salt instead of washing it down. When the
sun dried the water out, the land cracked into small squares, tearing
apart the roots of young plants. The people voted with their feet
against irrigation, despairing of ever producing bumper crops, and
turned their attention to sidelines, contract work in nearby
industries, and even speculation.
A notorious example of local entrepreneurship was Li Hongchang, a bachelor who used to ride freight trains into
Hard work to transform the land was further inhibited by changes
in ownership. Long Bow had already lost more than one third of its
acreage to the railroad, the city-owned cement plant and the saw-blade
works. The brigade was compensated for the loss of land by cash
payments equal in value to three years of crops, but the saw-blade
plant ruined an irrigation project, imposed from above, on which the
peasants had expended tens of thousands of labor-days. That labor was
never repaid.
The Taihang Saw Blade Works moved to Long Bow from coastal
The educated youth, with their
These tenants wear clothes, display hair styles, sing tunes, and
use words different from those that Long Bow people are used to. Close
contact with them has changed local customs in inconspicuous ways that
add up. After a few years of this, Long Bow people find themselves
already quite up-to-date compared with peasants who live only a few
miles from the railroad, in what the initiated have come to regard as
backcountry.
One result of the new sophistication is that Long Bow leaders
find it increasingly hard to hold meetings, because there is always a
play being performed or a film being shown nearby. These films may be
spy thrillers, historical dramas about events before the 1950s,
romances in which boy meets girl on a construction project, or foreign
films from
It is now all but impossible to marry a Long Bow girl unless one
is willing to move into Long Bow, because the sophisticated young women
there will not leave home, certainly not for any village without
quarter-hourly bus service to
In principle, young people in rural
But Long Bow is unusually heterogeneous, and young people can
sometimes meet and marry inside the village. One who did so in spite of
going away to school is Li Lingchiao, a stunning young woman with
braids down her back that fall all the way to her waist (at least they
did until she cut them off in 1978). Her lips are so formed that they
are almost always open, making her seem eager, even slightly
breathless. She is vice-leader of the women's association and a member
of the brigade's Community Party branch. As a communist, she should
have waited until she was twenty-five to marry, and her husband should
have waited until he was twenty-eight. But she was married at the age
of twenty to a young man of the same age who had been her classmate in
the middle school run by the commune at
She blushed when I asked her about this but explained that her
husband's father had been very ill and wanted his son to get married
before he died. She didn't want to break the rules, but he was so
miserable that she was consumed by pity and agreed to marry the young
man. His father, she told me, jumped up from his pallet after that and
hasn't been sick a day since.
"But how did you get a license? You were not really old enough."
"We didn't go to our commune office in
If meeting nonrelated young people was the essential condition
for free choice in marriage, the educated youth in Long Bow were in an
enviable situation. They all lived together in a large two-story
building on the site once occupied by the
They all blushed. They all denied that any such thought had ever
crossed their minds. They all said that they were too young to be
thinking about such things as love and marriage, and even though I
pressed them very hard, I could not break this solid front.
Chang was an ex-soldier from
"I have discovered," he said to me one day, "that there are still a few hates here."
What he meant by "hates" were hard feelings left over from the
Cultural Revolution that began in 1966 and ended sometime between 1970
and 1976, depending on whom you asked. The wounds inflicted by years of
bitter factional conflict over who should hold power in the community
had been slow to heal.
In the evening, Chang and I used to go outside the gate of the
compound and squat in the street, peasant-style, to watch the passing
scene. Chang owned a raucous little portable radio that had cost him 13
yuan ($8). He always turned it to
One night an older man began to curse out the notorious "Little"
Li Hongen, who had led the people of the south end of the village when
they seized power in 1967. Seizing power meant occupying the brigade
office and taking over the official seals. With seals in hand, one
could stamp brigade documents, making them official. Above all, one
could spend brigade money.
Little Li was a communist of the older generation who backed the
young people of Stormy Petrel and Shanggan Ridge, two mass
organizations modeled on the student Red Guards who were agitating for
power all over the country that year.
When the Stormy Petrel (named after the bird in Gorki's poem
"Song of the Stormy Petrel") and Shanggan Ridge (named after a battle
in the Korean war) cadres took over the brigade office, they overthrew
Shi Shuangguei, the party secretary, and his younger brother, Wang
Jinhong, the party vice-secretary. But the rebels couldn't hold on to
their power. Most people refused to carry out their orders. After about
a week, they were forced to turn the seals over to the Takeover
Committee, set up by five other hastily assembled village organizations
with names like Truth Fighting Team and Expose Schemes Battle Corps.
Within a month power was turned back to Wang as the new party
secretary.
To consolidate their power, it was necessary for the five
"loyalist" groups to put the "rebels" down and keep them down. They had
to make the rebels and their ancestors stink to high heaven, forever.
Little Li and the leaders of Stormy Petrel and Shanggan Ridge were
denounced as "landlords, rich peasants, counterrevolutionaries and bad
elements" who were trying to "reverse the case" on land reform and
bring back feudalism. They were arrested, beaten, and driven out of the
village. When they ran out of grain, grain coupons and the hospitality
of relatives in outlying counties, they returned to Long Bow, only to
be arrested, beaten, and driven out again. It was late 1969 before they
were able to come home and stay home, and late 1971 before the label
"counterrevolutionary" was officially removed from the record. By that
time, the charges had penetrated so deeply into the popular
consciousness that they could not easily be erased. Years later, an old
man on the street could still curse Little Li for trying to "reverse
the case" on land reform.
The first person killed in the Cultural Revolution in
"When I think about it, it frightens me," said Wang Jinhong, now
chairman but no longer party secretary of the Long Bow Brigade. In the
struggle here, we could easily have killed someone. Brigade members
could have died just as that student did. We were lucky. Things never
went that far, but it scares me to think about it."
"Do you really think that the rebels were 'landlords, rich
peasants, counterrevolutionaries, and bad elements?'" I asked.
"I don't now, but I did then. We convinced ourselves of it. The
wind of denunciation was blowing through the whole region. Everybody
thought their opposition was counterrevolutionary."
Wang Jinhong has been in and out of local office so often that
his career resembles that of Vice-Premier Deng Xiaoping at the national
level. Since 1966, he has been twice overthrown and three times
elevated to top posts in the brigade. Physically, Jinhong stands out
because of his massive forehead and the fact that he is slightly
hunchbacked. He carried loads that were too heavy for him when he was
little, and the carrying pole bent his back and thrust his head
permanently forward. This makes him look, when he walks, as if he
cannot wait to get where he is going and is searching somewhat
anxiously for a quicker way to his goal. This impression matches his
true character. Jinhong is indeed eager, inquisitive, impatient -- and
very smart.
After he came back to power as party secretary in 1967, he led
the village through the last years of the Cultural Revolution. Later,
he was held responsible for the factional excesses that had shattered
unity and undermined production. But he was caught up in events that no
one could control. How could a brigade leader be blamed when the
People's Liberation Army general, who was charged with reconciling the
factions in the region, instead framed the civilian who was his rival
for the top post, calling him a Kuomintang agent?
Whatever his share of the blame, Wang Jinhong was removed from office in 1971 by a work team sent from
The fact of the matter was that Jinhong was technically the most
skillful and politically the most farsighted man in Long Bow. He had
been recruited as an apprentice electrician in 1958 and had spent four
years as a power plant construction worker on projects all over north
Finally, in 1973, Wang Jinhong was restored to office. He
criticized himself, accepted some responsibility for the factionalism
of the 1960s, and vowed to unite with others to change things in Long
Bow. That was the turning point. Wang Jinhong and the leaders who had
temporarily replaced him put their differences aside and concentrated
on making some sort of breakthrough in production. That they succeeded
is illustrated by the steady rise in grain yields from 28 bushels per
acre in 1970, the approximate level for the previous twenty years, to
48 bushels in 1973, then 60 in 1974, and 100 in 1979.
I was fascinated by this sudden leap in production. Obviously it
had awaited a political settlement that could unite the brigade. But
once the brigade united, there was still the technical question -- how
had the problem of the alkalinity of Long Bow's soil been overcome?
"Ever since we lost so much land to industry." Jinhong said, "we
have been growing more and more market vegetables. To make them grow,
we get the night soil, the kitchen waste and the ashes from the
workers' homes. We found that when we put a lot of coal ashes on the
soil, the salt receded. It got washed down, not sucked up.
"Then we noticed something strange," he continued. "At the power
plant near Yellow Mill, the great chimney threw ashes all over the
countryside. People protested, but the plant managers did nothing. In a
circle around the plant, the crops all turned gray. But every year,
they grew better than the year before. It was the ashes. They did
something to the heavy clay. They increased the percolation.
"So we put the schoolchildren to work at an experiment
supervised by Shen Majin's research group. They hauled ashes from the
waste pile at the power plant and put them on their experimental plot,
over 100 tons to the acre. We covered the land three to four inches
deep. It worked. The yields almost doubled. So after that, we put all
the production teams to work hauling ashes. Each year, each team
converted some of its land.
"Once the land was converted, we could irrigate. We had to dig
more wells, pump more water, divert more water from the reservoir, fix
up irrigation channels and level the land. That took a lot of labor.
Our best people used to be out earning money at various jobs --
unloading freight at the railroad station, cutting steel bars at the
steel mill, hauling rock by handcart for the cement mill. We had to
call them all home.
"For the first time in twenty years, we put agriculture in first place, and it really paid off."
"Your sidelines seem to be flourishing, too," I said.
"Well, we concentrated on sidelines that could use partial labor
power -- like the teenage girls. They are polishing the saw blades and
making the saw handles for the saw-blade works. We needed wood for the
saw handles, so we bought a sawmill. Of course, that takes skilled
people. We needed phosphate fertilizer, but we found we could only buy
the raw rock. So we set up a grinding mill. Then we converted it into a
cement plant. With some of that output, we can supply the raw material
for lining our irrigation canals. All these projects are very
profitable, much more so than the wages we used to earn outside. Twelve
percent of our labor power working at sidelines now produces seventy
percent of our income.
Wang Jinhong, the brigade chairman, can enjoy play as well as
work, tradition as well as change. For example, he joined the Long Bow
village stilt dancers when the people went to
Stilts are a very old tradition in Shanxi Province, but only
Long bow has stilt dancers who do acrobatics, jump over tables, and
climb up and down ramps. The village learned this kind of stilt walking
from a captured Kuomintang officer who was "reeducated" there in 1945,
when the Communists' famous
The dancers stood so tall on their stilts that even the shortest
of them looked down on the musicians playing on the high, jolting bed
of a four-wheeled trailer drawn through the city streets by tractor.
The horn player's cheeks puffed out like two swollen bladders. His
fingers moved so swiftly that they blurred. Sometimes he held the horn
away from his face and blew through the reed alone. This sounded like
two turkeys in a forest squaring off for battle. The bamboo pipes, the
snakeskin fiddles, and the bulging red drums of the other performers
fell silent to let the turkeys quarrel, then suddenly resumed their
frantic rhythm as the horn, two octaves lower now, rejoined its reed.
The music
trailer, with its long double line of elevated dancers, moved slowly
down the city streets through dense crowds of celebrants. Ahead and
behind it moved other floats, other performers, other dancers, and
acrobats, some of them also on stilts, in what seemed to be an endless
procession. Their motion on the street generated a dense cloud of dust
that softened all outlines. Through the dust, one could look ahead to
see villagers holding costumed children high overhead on flexible
poles, and behind to see factory workers dip and roll various huge
papier-mâché figures. A second trailer carried a pyramid of opera stars
made up to resemble the heroes of Water Margin, the men driven onto
We were all out in the fields wielding our heavy, mattock like
hoes. Smash. Drive the blade in, pull the soil back, break the biggest
lumps. Smash, drive the blade in again . . . try not to take any extra
steps, they compact the soil.
"How long is it going to be?" asked Jinhong.
"How long is what going to be?"
"This bit with the hoe! We're stuck here with hoes in our hands
one thousand, two thousand, three thousand years. It's time to get rid
of these jewels."
"That it is," I said.
"I'm not afraid of hard work. I'm willing to hoe alongside the next man. But I don't like it. In
"It's hard to run a tractor through a field when you have two crops growing together."
"Never mind two crops. We'll plant corn alone until we learn to
do it with machines. And we'll push up yields while we do it."
"Do you mean that?"
"Yes."
"What will the commune say?"
"That's a problem. When you try things in
'What are
you trying to do? Set up your own Central Committee?' The technical
question turns into a political question. You are violating democratic
centralism."
"That makes it hard. How can you experiment with anything?"
"It isn't easy. But really, here in the brigade we are in a
better position than anyone else to try things. Take mechanization. We
have land, labor power, money, and materials. What materials we don't
have, we can usually find. Who else has that kind of leverage? The
supply departments have materials, but no labor power. The factories
have labor power but no materials. The mechanization office has nothing
but a sign on the door. What can those fellows do but talk?"
Wang Jinhong was not content with mere talk. He went ahead on
his own without regard to the consequences. In 1977, he asked me such
questions as, How would you put grain on the second floor of the office
building? How would you irrigate corn land? How would you dry grain? I
suggested a grain auger, a center-pivot irrigation system, and a
coal-fired grain drier. (A grain auger is like a long, unbroken screw
or drill bit that carries grain up the spiral formed by its turning
threads. A center-pivot irrigation system is a pipe up to half a mile
long, mounted on wheels every few yards; it turns in a huge circle
around a well at the center, which provides water for the pipe to spray
at intervals up to the outer circumference.)
Instead of saying, as so many in
Then in 1979, he launched a 100-acre experiment in the
mechanization of corn farming. With some equipment borrowed from the
Mechanization Institute of the province, with other equipment built in
Long Bow, and with support and advice from various levels of the
government, his special team produced over twenty-five tons of grain
per worker, a fourteen fold increase in productivity in one year.
This achievement had extraordinary implications. It meant that
for every person left raising crops, fourteen could leave the land and
do something else. In Long Bow, they could probably be absorbed
manufacturing grain augers, irrigation systems and grain driers -- if
the state supported the idea with the necessary supplies
That was a big "if." My impression was that
Nevertheless, in the fall of 1978, the government did take
concrete steps to untie the hands of peasant innovators.
Jinhong had been sick for three days. Since nothing seemed to be
happening on the street and nobody came or went through the big door of
the brigade office except the accountant, we decided to go and find out
where all the action had gone. Gatekeeper Zhang and I followed the only
person who seemed to be heading anywhere. His trail led straight to
Jinhong's home.
The main section of the house was ample in size. There was a
low-ceilinged living room about 15 feet long, then a doorway leading to
a dimly lit bedroom on the east. The main room was full of people,
about ten in all, and there were two more in the bedroom talking to
Jinhong, who was lying fully dressed on a wide wooden bed. Manfu, the
opera lover from the saw-blade shop, lean Chou-fa covered with grime
after a twelve-hour shift in the cement mill, Wende from the Fifth Team
garden, reeking of raw pig manure, two capped and jacketed buyers from
a trading organization in the city, and a messenger from Horse Square
Commune milled about, waiting their turn and all talking at once. In
the cookhouse outside, Dr. Shen of the brigade clinic was brewing a
special cough medicine
out of
herbs. He had to compete for space on the adobe stove with Jinhong's
willful daughter, who was heating some gruel for her father.
When the two men in the bedroom came out -- they were leaders of
a neighboring brigade -- the two buyers went in. As they ducked through
the door, each pulled a pack of cigarettes from his pocket. It was a
conditioned reflex. Prior to doing business, one offered a cigarette.
Seeing this, Chang called me into a corner for a confidential
aside. When dealing with certain industrial units and certain notorious
functionaries, he said, buyers from the countryside had to be prepared
with three kinds of armament -- the twenty-shot clip (pack of
name-brand cigarettes), the hand grenade (bottle of fine wine), and the
explosive satchel (box of sweet biscuits). Working out the terms of a
deal had come to be known as yen chiu, yen chiu, which
means "to study the question" -- but also means "cigarettes and wine,
cigarettes and wine." Needless to say, Jinhong had no use for any such
preliminaries. His policy was to judge each offer on its merits.
While we waited for the buyers to complete their business --
they wanted guarantees on a large order of cement -- three other people
came in. One was a cadre from the Railroad Construction Bureau who
wanted to negotiate the transfer of more Long Bow land. The second was
the head mechanic from the trucking depot at the railroad yards. He had
completed repairs on one of Long Bow's tractors. The last one in was
Zhang Wenying, head of the women's association. What she had to
announce, with her usual good cheer, was that a delegation of sanitary
inspectors was on its way. She wanted people mobilized to sweep the
streets. Dr. Shen offered her a cigarette. She lit it from the burned
stub already in her mouth.
"Two more women have agreed to have their tubes tied," she said.
"How many does that make altogether?"
"Fifty this year."
It was a commune record.
Jinhong suddenly appeared out of the bedroom, concerned that we had not been offered tea.
"Aren't you supposed to be sick?" I asked.
"Oh, it's not that bad. I'm almost well now," he protested with a voice
that
faded halfway through the sentence. Then he coughed, a rasping sound
that came from deep in his chest. He didn't sound well to me, but no
one else seemed worried. The dampness underfoot aggravated coughs, and
so did the dust in the air. Within a few hours after every rain the
dust blew up again because so much of the earth was bare. You could
feel grit in your mouth whenever you clenched your teeth.
It did Jinhong little good to stay home. The affairs of the
brigade followed him day and night. They were ever present, like the
dust. But his spirit, if not his body, thrived on the challenge. And I
could see why. I had a strong sense, sitting there that day, of the
vitality the raw energy, the unleashed creative power of the
cooperative and its 2,000 members. There had been years of stagnation.
They could be repeated. But right now the sluices were open, and almost
everyone was wading out to do battle -- remaking the soil, bringing in
water, setting up industries, building homes, taking hold of birth
control, planning a new school, sending out buyers to places as distant
as Shanghai and Harbin. Above all, they had the temerity to challenge
the age-old dominance of the hoe. That impressed me the most.
Next: A trip to Fengyan County1983
Back to the Contents page